Category: Quotes

“Preserve, protect and defend…”

On my conservative, Republican grandfather’s 131st birthday, here’s Donald Trump’s latest attempt to put his personal interest ahead of his Constitutional oath. Ironically, his Stop the Steal falsehoods coincided with his efforts to overturn, i.e., steal, the most transparent, scrutinized and litigated election in memory. Some responses:

Trump’s Call for ‘Termination’ of Constitution Draws Rebukes,” by Maggie Astor, The New York Times, December 4, 2022.

Lawmakers react to Trump’s call to suspend Constitution,” by Ivana Saric, Axios, December 4, 2022.

Trump rebuked for call to suspend Constitution over election,” by Hope Yen/AP, The Washington Post, December 4, 2022.

From “Are The Frogs Boiled?” by Joyce Vance, Civil Discourse, December 4, 2022

Markers

My wife Cathey keeps a brief daily journal. She reviews what she wrote one year ago and two years ago. Sometimes we marvel at how much has changed. Sometimes we marvel how (especially with Donald Trump), it’s another verse of the same song.

You’re reading my “journal.” This is #1,156 since September 30, 2019. Its purpose is to further the dialogue with our son (and anyone else who’s interested) about the day’s events–to leave a “time stamped” record of what the old man is thinking.

Around 11 pm on Saturday, Heather Cox Richardson posted an installment of Letters from an American. Her opening sentence: I hate to break up a holiday weekend with a political post, but I want to put down a marker for the record. It was about Trump’s dinner meeting that included Ye, aka Kanye West, and white supremacist Nick Fuentes.

One of HCR’s phrases has lingered with me: “to put down a marker for the record.” I’ve been flooded with encouraging and challenging “markers.” In this week’s posts I’ll share some markers that I want to put down for the record.

My great-grandfather Sam Combs put down some markers in a journal of a 3,500-mile trip from Berea, Kentucky by train to Jellico, Tennessee; by automobile (a “machine”) with his son-in-law, my grandfather, to Tampa, then Miami; by train from Jacksonville to Memphis, Little Rock, Hot Springs, then to Berea. One “marker” was the new Wilson Dam.

The first page of Sam Combs’ two-month journal begins on December 2, 1924. He ended the journal by saying it was a great learning experience but six months too short.

Moving beyond tribalism

When I encounter tribalism, my instinct is to take a hot shower and have a cup of coffee with Pierre Teilhard de Chardin (1881-1955), a French Roman Catholic priest in the Jesuit order. He died in relative obscurity before my fifth birthday, so my sessions with him are through his writing, much of which was published after his death. The Divine Milieu has been a favorite since seminary days.

Many consider Le Phénomène Humain (written in the 1930s) his masterpiece. It was translated into English in 1959 as The Phenomenon of Man. A later translation by Sarah Appleton-Weber was published in 2003 as The Human Phenomenon. It took me 19 years to buy it, so there’s no telling when I’ll finish reading it, but I’ll start on Saturday, when it should arrive.

Teilhard was a paleontologist with a rich understanding of the Universe. An occasional dose of his writing reminds me to move beyond tribal, parochial thinking to focus on the Big Picture.

From The Divine Milieu (p. 59):

… We shall be astonished at the extent and the intimacy of our relationship with the universe.

… the roots of our being …. plunge back and down into the unfathomable past. How great is the mystery…. How possible to decipher the welding of successive influences in which we are forever incorporated! In each one of us, through matter, the whole history of the world is in part reflected.

“From “Pierre Teilhard de Chardin: prophet of cosmic hope,” by Susan Rakoczy, openDemocracy, February 18, 2020

Let’s pretend

When I was a child, the neighborhood kids sometimes played a game called “let’s pretend,” although we called it “let’s play like.” There are computer versions of this in the metaverse. Today, the ability to play “let’s pretend” is a popular path to success in the Republican Party.

Liz Cheney is leaving Congress after just three terms because she chose not to play the game. Harriet Hageman will be Wyoming’s new representative. Hageman supported Cheney in 2016 when Cheney was first elected to Congress. That year, Hageman opposed the presidential candidacy of Donald Trump, calling him “racist and xenophobic.” This was before she learned to play the game.

Today, a more-timely-than-I-want-to-admit read is “Why People Flocked To Hitler, And Why The Nazis Believed ‘Here There Is No Why,’” by Pramod K. Nayar in The Wire (August 31, 2021), based on Theodore Abel’s 1938 book, Why Hitler Came Into Power.

On this day after Wyoming’s primary, Cheney’s statement to her Trump-supporting colleagues is relevant: “There will come a day when Donald Trump is gone, but your dishonor will remain.”

From “Liz Cheney Was Brave When the Country Needed Her to Be,” by Michael A. Cohen, an opinion piece in The Daily Beast, August 17, 2022

Hope–more than optimism

I’m a 1950 white American male. I thought Ozzie and Harriet Nelson were neighbors. I thought Vin Scully called our little league baseball games. I lived with naive optimism. I believed America saved the world from fascism and could accomplish anything.

Now, in my 72nd lap around the sun, the naive optimism is gone. That’s a good thing. Optimism isn’t bad. It’s better than pessimism. What’s best is realism, a wisdom marked by wrinkled skin and creases not yet paralyzed by botox.

I’m not optimistic about America, but I’m more patriotic than ever about being an American, receiving with gratitude the imperfect idealism of our Founders and determined to live (like Lincoln) with malice toward none and charity for all.

I’m hopeful. Hope isn’t dependent on any party, executive, legislature or court. Hope is rooted in self-evident truths that transcend every institution, government, religion and ideology. We can respond to any situation with hope. Hope is more than optimism.

A paraphrase from Viktor Frankl, Man’s Search fpr Meaning

Our real work

I’ve been mulling the Declaration‘s complaint that the British people weren’t acting with magnanimity or a spirit of kinship. Almost 250 years later, are we any better at it than they were?

With that on my mind, my friend Don sent a quote from Wendell Berry, 87, a farmer, poet and writer who has inspired me over the decades. It’s from his 1983 book Standing by Words, p. 104, Catapult (Kindle edition), and it is especially helpful at this painful, almost overwhelming moment in history:

It may be that when we no longer know what to do we have come to our real work and that when we no longer know which way to go we have begun our real journey. The mind that is not baffled is not employed. The impeded stream is the one that sings.”

A young Wendell Berry and a statue of his great grandfather, from “The Thing (or Things) About Wendell Berry,” by Mark Bittman, Humanities, May/June, 2012

For some, it’s not a metaphor

The recent Southern Lights conference took place three days after the massacre at the Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas and less than two weeks before the beginning of public hearings by the House Select Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack on the United States Capitol.

Here are excerpts from a May 27 “Why Southern Lights?” presentation by Diana Butler Bass:

One way to understand what the NRA is currently doing (is to see it as) no longer a gun safety organization, no longer a fellowship for people who want to learn how to use guns well, no longer an organization that’s just about honoring hunters and traditions and all of those kinds of things. But I think we can clearly see now that it has become an effort to arm white people for open civil war. 

Butler Bass said the movements to change the laws around abortion and women’s access to health care, the laws about our LBGTQ brothers and sisters, and the absolute need to control the teaching of race and racism and how teachers explore these issues in classrooms (are ways) to reinvigorate local powers to create a kind of state’s rights movement that will continue to divide the United States….

Referring to co-presenter Brian McLaren, Butler Bass said, Brian wrote this line and I stand with it and in it: “If people like us do nothing, the new Confederacy will continue to advance.”

McLaren responded: So those are sobering words, but I think January 6th was a wake-up call to tell us that there really are people when they use the word “culture war,” war was not merely a metaphor. And, so … people like us who happen to live in the South and do not believe the Gospel of Jesus Christ should be linked with white Christian nationalism have a very important role to play … with confidence in our hearts and to live it out loud in the South. 

From “Decoding the extremist symbols and groups at the Capitol Hill insurrection,” by Mallory Simon and Sara Sidner, with CNN Photo Illustrations by Priya Krishnakumar, CNN, January 11, 2021

All-inclusive

With age, I’ve tried to be more inclusive. Exclusion and inclusion are learned early—a necessary part of identity formation. Boundaries are set by parents, teachers, and society. It’s important to respect, and set, appropriate boundaries.

Over time, some boundaries are reinforced, and some are relaxed. Religions pay considerable attention to boundaries: Why include this group and exclude that group? Why is this, not that, kosher? I try to err on the side of inclusion.

Society’s boundaries are expressed through laws, ideally to seek justice, which is society’s way of expressing love. Some laws are unjust. We’re a work in progress. M.L. King, Jr., said, “The law can’t make a man love me, but it can restrain him from lynching me.”

The Fullness of Loving Relationships website has a page entitled “All-Inclusive,” devoted to Personal Health, Social Justice and Ecological Justice.

From fullnessofloving.com

Light overcomes darkness

The Epilogue to Jon Meacham’s John Lewis and the Power of Hope takes its title, “Against the Rulers of Darkness,” from the New Testament letter to the Ephesians: “For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world.”

Sometimes, when I feel overwhelmed or brought low by “the world,” I’m renewed by the words and music of the Civil Rights movement. The movement’s heyday was during my formative years. I was 6 when the Montgomery Bus Boycott ended; 12 when the Sixteenth Street Baptist Church was bombed; 14 when Selma’s “Bloody Sunday” occurred; and 17 when Martin Luther King, Jr., was slain.

When I heard of the Buffalo tragedy, I turned to Meacham’s Epilogue about Lewis: The movement of which Lewis had been an integral part had done more to change America for the better than any single domestic undertaking since the Civil War, joining emancipation and women’s suffrage as brilliant chapters in an uneven and yet unfolding national story.

We’re in a not-so-brilliant time. But, neither were the years ’56, ’63, ’65 and ’68. That era was a “brilliant chapter” because people like King and Lewis were undeterred by the darkness. As a young man–little more than a child, really–(Lewis) had contended against evil with everything he had. And he prevailed.

From “70 John Lewis Quotes That Shed Light on Justice and More,” by Amy Finn, QuoteAmbition